CONTACT

Awaab’s Law, Private Landlords and Expert Evidence: Who May Investigate a Hazard and What It Means for Wimbledon Disrepair Claims (November 2026)

Should a private landlord be allowed to decide for themselves who is competent to investigate damp, mould or another hazard, or should the law require a qualified person such as a building surveyor? That is Question 12 of the government's consultation on extending Awaab's Law to private rented homes, which opened on 9 October 2026 and closes at 11.59pm on 18 December 2026 [1]. On Awaab's Law, private landlords and expert evidence are now tied together: the person who carries out the first investigation, and the written summary they produce, are likely to become the opening documents in any later disrepair claim.

Key Takeaways

  • The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government is consulting until 18 December 2026 on applying Awaab's Law to private rented tenancies and to some licensed accommodation in England [1].
  • Question 12 offers three models for who may investigate: anyone the landlord judges competent, a two-stage process with a specialist follow-up, or someone with specific qualifications, with a building surveyor given as an example [1].
  • The duty would sit in the tenancy as an implied term. A tenant could sue for breach of contract, and a court could order repairs, compensation and costs [1].
  • An Awaab's Law investigation is not a court expert report. Expert evidence in a claim is still governed by CPR Part 35 and the housing conditions pre-action protocol [2][3].
  • No start date is fixed. The consultation says the earliest feasible date is 2027 [1].

What has been announced, and when?

The consultation paper, "Extending Awaab's Law to private rented tenancies and to licences", was published by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government on 9 October 2026. It applies to England only [1].

Awaab's Law is named after Awaab Ishak, who was two years old when he died in 2020 [4]. It already applies to social housing. Since 27 October 2025 social landlords have had to deal with damp and mould and with emergency hazards inside fixed timescales. A second phase covering further hazards is due on 30 November 2026, subject to Parliament, with remaining hazards planned for 2027 [1].

The Renters' Rights Act 2025 lets the government bring the same idea into private renting. The paper describes the private sector as very different from the social sector, and gives these figures [1]:

  • Private renting has at least 2.3 million landlords.
  • 82% of private landlords own fewer than five rental properties.
  • 94% let property as a private individual.

Most private landlords have no repairs team and no surveyor on call, which is why the investigation questions are the heart of the paper.

What does the consultation propose on investigations?

The paper starts from the social housing model and asks whether each part should be copied or changed [1].

Step Social housing rule now Options put to private landlords
Investigate a potential significant hazard Within 10 working days 5, 10 or 15 working days (Question 11)
Who investigates A person the landlord judges competent Competent person, two-stage process, or qualified person (Question 12)
Written summary to the tenant Within 3 working days of the investigation ending Whether to require one, how fast, and what it must say (Questions 14 to 16)
Emergency hazards Investigate and make safe within 24 hours 12, 24 or 48 hours (Question 23)

The three options in Question 12

The paper asks who should be able to carry out Awaab's Law inspections in the private rented sector, and offers [1]:

  1. "any person who, in the landlord's judgement, is competent to assess the risk posed to an occupier by the potential hazard", which mirrors the social housing rule;
  2. "a 2-stage process in which the landlord or agent can make an initial assessment and then, if required, arrange for a specialist to carry out a follow up inspection";
  3. "someone with specific relevant qualifications, for example, a Housing Health and Safety Rating System practitioner or a building surveyor".

The government expects arguments

Question 13 asks how big a challenge three things would be: the cost of investigations, the availability of suitably competent people, and "disputes about investigation outcomes, for example, whether a hazard meets the threshold" [1]. The government plainly expects investigation results to be contested.

The National Residential Landlords Association supports the extension but says the rules must reflect how the sector works [4].

How would a breach be enforced?

The route is through the tenancy agreement. The paper explains that the Renters' Rights Act 2025 inserts an implied term into private tenancies requiring the landlord to comply with Awaab's Law. If the landlord does not, "the tenant will be able to take them to court for a breach of contract". The court can then order repairs, compensation, and payment of some or all of the tenant's legal costs [1].

Tenants could also complain to the new Private Rented Sector Landlord Ombudsman once it exists. Councils keep their existing powers, including a financial penalty of up to £7,000 where a landlord has failed to take reasonably practicable steps to keep a home free of category 1 hazards [1].

Two further points shape the evidence:

  • A defence. Social landlords have a defence if they can prove they took all reasonable steps to comply but could not, for reasons genuinely beyond their control. The paper considers the same approach for private landlords [1]. A defence that must be proved needs records.
  • No "lifestyle" shortcut. The paper proposes to exclude hazards caused by a tenant's breach of contract. It adds that this does not mean landlords can avoid action on damp and mould "based on assumptions about these being caused by tenant 'lifestyle'" [1].

Awaab's Law, private landlords and expert evidence: where the surveyor fits

There are two different documents, with two different jobs.

The Awaab's Law investigation is a landlord's compliance step. Its purpose is to find out, quickly, whether there is a significant or emergency hazard and what must be done. Under the first option in Question 12 it could be carried out by anyone the landlord judges competent.

An expert report for court is something else. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, expert evidence is "restricted to that which is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings". The expert's duty is "to help the court on matters within their expertise", and that duty "overrides any obligation to the person from whom experts have received instructions or by whom they are paid". No party may rely on an expert's report without the court's permission [3]. See this guide to what an expert witness is in surveying disputes.

The Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England) already applies to private as well as social landlords. Its expert section sets out a clear path [2]:

  • The tenant's letter of claim names a proposed expert.
  • If the landlord does not object within 20 working days, that expert is instructed as a single joint expert.
  • If a joint expert cannot be agreed, the parties should try to arrange a joint inspection by their separate experts.
  • The inspection should take place within 20 working days of the landlord's response, and the report should follow within 10 working days of the inspection.
  • With a single joint expert, each side pays half of the fee.

Why the first investigation still matters in court

Even though it is not a Part 35 report, the investigation record will be evidence of fact. It will show what was seen, on what date, and what the landlord then knew. If the consultation leads to rules like those in social housing, a later expert surveyor is likely to be asked:

  • Was there a hazard at the date of the investigation, and did it meet the threshold?
  • What caused it: a building defect, or something else?
  • Were the works identified the right works?
  • Were they done within the required time, and were they effective?

The person who investigates first writes the first page of the evidence.

A recent county court example of the gap

A judgment handed down on 15 July 2026 shows what happens when there is no expert evidence at all. In Kemp v Henderson Property Management Solutions Ltd, in the County Court at Southend, His Honour Judge Duddridge decided a private tenant's claim about damp, mould and cold without any surveyor's report. He relied on an improvement notice, messages, photographs and videos, and recorded that the lack of expert evidence made the cause harder to establish [5]. The tenant still succeeded: judgment for £39,417.62 plus interest against the immediate landlord, and £10,429.62 plus interest against the freeholder [5]. Tenants can win on contemporaneous records, and landlords with no reliable record of their own have little to answer with.

More background is in this overview of expert witness surveying in UK property disputes.

What the three options would mean for the evidence

  • Competent person model. Fast and flexible, but competence may itself be argued over later.
  • Two-stage model. The dispute is likely to shift to whether the second stage should have been triggered.
  • Qualified person model. The first record would be made by someone such as a building surveyor or a Housing Health and Safety Rating System practitioner. The paper itself flags the cost and availability of such people as possible challenges [1].

Whichever model is chosen, a surveyor who investigates for a landlord has acted for one side. If the matter reaches court, the parties will need to consider whether a separate independent expert should be instructed. The scope of an inspection is explained in this guide to what a chartered surveyor does and when one is needed.

What does this mean for landlords and tenants in Wimbledon and south-west London?

Nothing changes in law today: the proposals are not yet regulations. But existing repairing duties and the pre-action protocol already apply to private lets in Wimbledon, Merton and the rest of south-west London, as they do across England.

Practical points for local owners and occupiers:

  • Landlords and agents can respond to the consultation before 18 December 2026, particularly on Questions 11 to 13.
  • Keep dated records now. Reports of damp or other defects, inspection notes, photographs and contractor visits are the raw material of any later defence. A structured report helps, and this page describes what a damp survey report in London contains.
  • Know the baseline condition. A condition survey report at the start of a letting records the state of the property before any dispute arises.
  • Tenants should report problems in writing and keep copies, photographs and dates.
  • Other duties are arriving too. See the guide to the Renters' Rights Act landlord database for south-west London landlords.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Awaab's Law apply to private landlords now?

No. It currently applies to social housing. The consultation says the earliest feasible date for private tenancies is 2027 [1].

Will a private landlord have to hire a surveyor for every damp complaint?

That is not decided. Only one of the three options in Question 12 would require someone with specific qualifications, such as a building surveyor [1].

Is an Awaab's Law investigation the same as an expert report?

No. The investigation is a landlord's compliance step. An expert report for court is governed by CPR Part 35, needs the court's permission, and is written by an expert whose overriding duty is to the court [3].

What is a single joint expert in a housing conditions claim?

It is one expert instructed by both sides. Under the pre-action protocol, the tenant proposes an expert, and if the landlord does not object within 20 working days that expert is instructed jointly. Each side pays half of the cost [2].

Can a tenant win a disrepair claim without a surveyor's report?

It can happen. In Kemp v Henderson Property Management Solutions Ltd the court relied on an improvement notice, messages, photographs and videos. The judge noted that the absence of expert evidence made the cause harder to establish [5]. Each case depends on its own facts.

Conclusion

On its face the consultation is about timescales; underneath it is about proof. Who investigates, how quickly, and what they write down will shape the expert evidence in later disrepair claims. Next steps: read Questions 11 to 16, respond before 18 December 2026 if affected, tighten record keeping now, and follow the pre-action protocol on experts if a dispute begins.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Anyone involved in a dispute should take advice on their own circumstances.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, "Extending Awaab's Law to private rented tenancies and to licences" (consultation, 9 October 2026). gov.uk.
  2. Ministry of Justice, Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England). justice.gov.uk.
  3. Ministry of Justice, Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35 (Experts and Assessors). justice.gov.uk.
  4. National Residential Landlords Association, "Awaab's Law consultation launches" (9 October 2026). nrla.org.uk.
  5. Kemp v Henderson Property Management Solutions Ltd and another, County Court at Southend, HHJ Duddridge, judgment handed down 15 July 2026. judiciary.uk.