CONTACT

Triathlon Homes in the Supreme Court on 19 November 2026: Who Pays for Historic Cladding Defects, and What It Means for Building Surveyors and Leaseholders in Wimbledon

Around £1.1 million of fire safety costs were spent before a new law existed. Can that law still make a developer pay them back? On 19 November 2026, five Supreme Court justices are due to hear that question in the Triathlon Homes appeal about remediation contribution orders [1][2]. The answer will shape who carries the cost of historic cladding defects across England, including in blocks of flats in Wimbledon and south-west London.

Key Takeaways

  • Hearing date: 19 November 2026, though listings can change [1].
  • The issue: whether a remediation contribution order can cover costs incurred before 28 June 2022 [1][2].
  • So far: the First-tier Tribunal and the Court of Appeal both sided with Triathlon [1][2].
  • Not decided yet: judgment will follow later. The outcome is not known.
  • What to do now: keep cost records and obtain proper defect and external wall reports.

What Is a Remediation Contribution Order?

A remediation contribution order (RCO) is made under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA). It requires a developer, landlord or associated company to contribute to the cost of putting right relevant defects. The tribunal makes an order where it is "just and equitable" to do so [1].

The Dispute Behind the Triathlon Homes Supreme Court Appeal

The case concerns fire safety defects in the external walls of five residential blocks on the East Village Estate in Stratford, east London [1][2].

Party Role
Stratford Village Development Partnership (SVDP) Developed the blocks [1]
Get Living PLC Has effectively owned SVDP since 2018 [1]
East Village Management Ltd Manages the blocks [1]
Triathlon Homes LLP Holds the social housing in the blocks [1]

The Building Safety Fund agreed to pay for the major remediation works [1]. In December 2022, Triathlon applied for RCOs against SVDP and Get Living. It sought its share of remediation costs and other costs, such as investigation, a temporary waking watch and a temporary fire alarm [1]. Around £1.1 million of the claim related to costs incurred before 28 June 2022, the day section 124 came into force [2].

The First-tier Tribunal made the orders. The Court of Appeal upheld them, holding that section 124 can cover costs incurred before it came into force [1][2].

What the Supreme Court Will Consider

The appeal is listed before Lord Hamblen, Lord Burrows, Lord Leggatt, Lord Stephens and Lord Doherty. The Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government is an intervener [1].

The court's case summary lists two issues [1]:

  1. Whether the Court of Appeal took the wrong approach to "just and equitable".
  2. Whether an RCO can be made for costs incurred before 28 June 2022.

The court's permission record indicates that permission was granted in part, on the retrospectivity ground [1]. So the central question is the second one.

A linked appeal, Adriatic Land 5 Limited v Long Leaseholders at Hippersley Point, is listed for the day before, 18 November 2026. It asks a similar question about service charges [2][3].

The appeals affect how losses are allocated, not whether they exist.

That is how one law firm described the stakes. It also suggested that the outcome may increase the urgency of claims and the use of adjudication, and that there may be a window to settle disputes before judgment [2].

What Leaseholders, Freeholders and Managing Agents Should Do Now

No one should try to predict the result. But sensible steps can be taken while the judgment is awaited:

  • Keep every record. Invoices and dates for waking watch, alarms, surveys and investigations all matter. The date a cost was incurred is at the heart of this appeal.
  • Get the building properly assessed. A competent external wall assessment and a clear defect report are the foundation of any claim or defence.
  • Review live disputes. Where an RCO application or a related claim is under way, ask advisers how the appeal could affect it.
  • Do not delay safety works in the hope of clarity on cost.

The Building Surveyor's Role

Chartered building surveyors, often working with fire engineers, are involved from the first inspection:

  • identifying and recording defects in external walls and other parts of the building
  • explaining what the defects mean for safety and for repair
  • specifying remedial works and reviewing tenders
  • checking that work is done properly

Good records made at this stage carry real weight later.

Expert Evidence in Remediation Contribution Order Cases

RCO applications and related claims rely heavily on expert evidence. Experts are usually asked to address:

  • whether there is a relevant defect and a building safety risk
  • what remedial scheme is needed
  • whether the costs claimed are reasonable

An expert's duty is to the tribunal, not to the party paying the fee. Surveyors should note that the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and restates that duty in clear terms [4].

Frequently Asked Questions

When will the Supreme Court give judgment?
No date has been given. Judgment follows some time after the hearing.

Does this affect only Stratford?
No. The ruling will apply to RCO applications across England.

Has the Supreme Court looked at the Building Safety Act before?
Yes, once, in URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd in 2025 [2].

Should a leaseholder take action now?
Keep records and take advice on the specific building. The right step depends on the lease and the facts.

Conclusion

The Triathlon Homes Supreme Court hearing on remediation contribution orders will settle whether developers can be made to pay for safety costs that came before the Building Safety Act took effect. Until judgment arrives, the position set by the Court of Appeal stands.

The practical next step is the same whichever way the court rules: record costs carefully, have the building properly assessed by competent professionals, and take advice early.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.

References

  1. UK Supreme Court, case details for UKSC 2025/0156, Stratford Village Development Partnership and another v Triathlon Homes LLP and another. jcpc.uk.
  2. Clyde & Co, "Adriatic and Triathlon in the Supreme Court: BSA retrospectivity to be clarified" (19 October 2026). clydeco.com.
  3. UK Supreme Court, case details for UKSC 2025/0157, Adriatic Land 5 Limited v Long Leaseholders at Hippersley Point and another. supremecourt.uk.
  4. RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org.