CONTACT

Douglas v Channon (2026) EWHC 2475 (KB): Two Boundary Experts, a Hedge Stem’s Width and £108,402 in Costs, Expert Witness Lessons for Wimbledon Boundary Disputes (November 2026)

The two experts' lines differed by roughly the width of a hedge stem. The losing neighbour was ordered to pay 70% of the other side's costs, with £108,402 to be paid on account, and then lost again on appeal. Douglas v Channon, handed down by the High Court on 2 October 2026 and now circulating among practitioners, is a stark illustration of how a boundary dispute expert witness can shape, and fail to shape, the outcome of a neighbour dispute [1].

Key Takeaways

  • Mr Justice Linden dismissed an appeal against a Plymouth County Court decision fixing the boundary between 43 and 41 Mead Road, Torquay.
  • The trial judge accepted the defendant's expert on two of three sections of the boundary and treated the remaining difference, a matter of millimetres along a former hedge line, as de minimis.
  • Where a hedge belongs to one property, the boundary runs along the outer edge of its stems, not its foliage, following Collis v Amphlett and Avon Estates Ltd v Evans.
  • Appeal courts will rarely interfere with a trial judge's factual findings or costs discretion in boundary cases.
  • Wimbledon homeowners should expect any dispute over centimetres to be judged against the cost of litigating it.

The dispute

Sarah Douglas has owned 43 Mead Road, Torquay since 2017. Ronald Channon has owned 41 Mead Road since 2021. The boundary between them had historically been marked by a hedge, which was removed in 2018. A fence was built in 2022 [1].

Ms Douglas claimed the boundary lay along a line identified by her surveyor and brought related claims for trespass, nuisance, harassment and "stabilisation" damages. Mr Channon counterclaimed for a declaration based on a different line, plus damages [1].

At trial before HH Judge Mitchell in Plymouth County Court, the judge described the boundary as "by far and away the stand-out issue in the case" and made a site visit [1].

The two boundary dispute expert witnesses

Expert Instructed by Qualification Line
Mr Rackham Ms Douglas Boundary surveyor A1-H1-B
Mr Barber Mr Channon Civil engineer by qualification A-H-B

The trial judge accepted Mr Barber's position at the western end, point A, and along the straight stretch to point H. The live question was whether the former hedge section between H and B ran straight or curved [1].

Applying Collis v Amphlett and Avon Estates Ltd v Evans (2013) EWHC 1635, the judge held that where a hedge belongs to one property the boundary runs along the outer edge of the stems or "growers", not the outer foliage, so that the boundary does not migrate as the hedge grows. On that footing he found Mr Barber's line was "marginally out" by roughly the width of the hedge stems. That was a matter of millimetres, and therefore de minimis. He adopted Mr Barber's line as drawn on Joint Plan 3 [1].

Structural engineers on both sides gave evidence on the stabilisation claim, which failed [1].

A difference between two expert plots measured in millimetres was treated as immaterial. The court wanted a fixed, workable line, not a perfect one.

Costs: the number that mattered

Ms Douglas was ordered to pay 70% of Mr Channon's costs, with a payment on account of £108,402. The judge found that Mr Channon was the successful party overall [1].

The appeal

Ms Douglas appealed on the boundary location (Ground 1) and on costs (Ground 4). Mr Justice Linden heard the appeal in Bristol on 29 July 2026 and handed down judgment on 2 October 2026 [1].

Ground 1: the boundary

The appeal court held that the de minimis finding was open to the trial judge on the evidence. Further expert work or a further hearing was unnecessary. The ground was dismissed [1].

Ground 4: costs

The costs decision was within the judge's discretion. Mr Channon had succeeded on the central boundary issue, and the judge had reasonably reduced the order by 30% to reflect the parts of the case he lost. Applying the deference owed to factual and discretionary decisions under Henderson v Foxworth and Tanfern, the ground was dismissed [1].

The appeal failed in full [1].

Lessons for the boundary dispute expert witness

Start from the conveyance, not the fence

The court restated that the boundary is fixed by construing the earliest conveyance that created it, with topographical features used to illuminate where the line lay at that date. An expert plot that begins from the present-day fence and works backwards will carry little weight.

Apply the hedge convention

Where a hedge belongs to one side, the line runs along the outer face of the stems. Experts who plot to the foliage, or to the centre of the hedge, will be corrected, and their credibility on other points may suffer.

Agree survey control and a joint plan

Joint Plan 3 was the document the judge adopted. A shared base survey with agreed control points lets the court focus on the genuine differences between experts and removes arguments about measurement error.

Say when a difference does not matter

An expert who can tell the court that two plots differ by a few millimetres and that the difference has no practical consequence is more useful than one who defends every millimetre. The court will apply de minimis whether the experts invite it or not.

Remember the costs backdrop

Two sets of boundary experts and two sets of structural engineers were paid for in this case. The claimant now faces more than £108,000 on account alone. Experts should give early, candid advice about the value of what is in dispute.

CPR Part 35 and the RICS standard

Expert evidence in boundary claims is governed by CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35. The expert owes an overriding duty to the court, must set out the instructions received and the material relied on, must give reasons and any range of opinion, and must sign a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and reinforces independence and the clear separation of measured fact from professional opinion for chartered surveyors.

Why this matters in Wimbledon and Merton

Wimbledon, Raynes Park and Merton Park are full of Edwardian and inter-war gardens where hedges have been removed and replaced with fences over several ownerships. The original conveyance plans are often small-scale and imprecise. Douglas v Channon shows what happens when neighbours litigate over the resulting uncertainty: the court will fix a pragmatic line, and the party who loses the central issue will carry most of the costs.

What this means for Wimbledon homeowners

  • Before replacing a hedge with a fence, agree the line with your neighbour in writing and consider a measured survey.
  • If a dispute arises, obtain early advice on what the conveyance actually shows, and weigh the value of the strip against the likely cost.
  • Mediation or a jointly instructed surveyor is usually cheaper than two experts and a trial.

What this means for surveyors and solicitors

  • Instruct a single joint expert where proportionate; CPR Part 35 encourages it in lower-value disputes.
  • Insist on a joint plan with agreed control before reports are exchanged.
  • Solicitors should prepare clients for the de minimis principle and for costs orders that follow success on the central issue.

Conclusion

Douglas v Channon did not change the law of boundaries, but it shows how the law is applied: conveyance first, hedge stems not foliage, a fixed line rather than a perfect one, and costs that follow the main issue. For any boundary dispute expert witness instructed in Wimbledon or elsewhere, the message is to measure carefully, agree what can be agreed and tell the client plainly when the difference is not worth fighting over. The judgment is published on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].

References

  1. Sarah Douglas v Ronald Channon (2026) EWHC 2475 (KB), High Court (King's Bench Division), Mr Justice Linden, 2 October 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.