A tenant reports damp and mould throughout her flat, and then does not let the landlord's contractors in. The landlord asks the court for two things: an order that she give access, and permission to send a locksmith if she does not. On 16 November 2026 the County Court at Bromley gave the first and refused the second in Phoenix Community Housing Association (Bellingham & Downham) Ltd v Winch (2026) EWCC 69 [1]. The judgment is important reading for anyone dealing with housing disrepair and damp and mould inspection access, because county court judges now openly disagree on whether forced entry can be ordered at all.
Key Takeaways
- Access injunction granted. The tenant must give access on 24 hours' written notice.
- Forced entry refused. District Judge Cridge held that a court has no power to permit a landlord to force entry to enforce a contractual right of access.
- A tenancy clause does not change that. Even an express contractual right to force entry made no difference to the answer.
- Judges are divided. The judge expressly disagreed with other 2026 County Court decisions that went the other way. Related claims have been transferred to the High Court.
- Damp and mould as an "emergency" was doubted. The judge questioned whether it could count as an emergency under the tenancy, though he assumed it could for the purposes of his decision.
What happened
The property is a first-floor flat in London SE9, let by a registered social housing provider on an assured tenancy that began on 7 July 2008. On 8 May 2026 the tenant reported damp and mould throughout the flat.
The landlord made repeated attempts to arrange access in May and June. Some appointments were agreed, but access was not given when contractors attended. Proceedings were issued on 25 September 2026.
The landlord relied on access clauses in the tenancy agreement and on section 11(6) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. That subsection gives a landlord the right to enter to view the condition and state of repair of a home at reasonable times, on 24 hours' written notice.
The hearing took place on 21 October 2026. The tenant did not attend and filed no evidence. The only evidence was a witness statement from the landlord's housing officer, which the judge accepted.
The two questions the court answered
The judge framed the issues like this:
- Does a court have power to permit a landlord to force entry to enforce an express or implied contractual right of access?
- Does a contractual right to force entry make a difference?
He answered no to both.
The usual way to enforce an injunction is through the court's contempt powers if the order is breached. The landlord wanted a single "rolled up" order that would let it bring a locksmith after a further 24 hours' notice. The judge reviewed the statutes, the Civil Procedure Rules and the case law at length, and concluded that the court could not authorise that step.
A split in the County Court
This is not the first judgment on the point, and that is why it matters.
| Decision | Court | Result on forced entry |
|---|---|---|
| Southern Housing v Emmanuel (2025) EWCC 58 | County Court (the same judge) | Refused |
| Stonewater v Harris (2026) EWCC 42 | County Court | Contrary to the view in Winch |
| Bromford v Robinson (2026) EWCC 61 | County Court | Contrary to the view in Winch |
| Phoenix v Winch (2026) EWCC 69 | County Court at Bromley | Refused |
First-instance County Court decisions do not bind other judges. The judgment records that related forced-entry claims were transferred to the High Court in September 2026, so a ruling from a higher court is awaited. Until then, landlords cannot assume that a forced-entry order will be available.
An injunction tells the tenant to open the door. On this judge's view, it does not let the landlord open it for her.
Why this matters for damp and mould investigations
Social landlords are under growing pressure to deal with damp and mould quickly. Awaab's Law has, since October 2025, set fixed time limits for social landlords to investigate and act on significant damp and mould hazards. A landlord who cannot get in cannot inspect, and a surveyor who cannot inspect cannot find the cause.
The judgment shows the gap between a duty to act quickly and the tools the court will provide. In this case more than five months passed between the first report in May and the hearing in October.
Housing disrepair and damp and mould inspection access: practical lessons
For landlords and managing agents
- Record every access attempt. Dates, times, letters, texts and what the operative found at the door. The landlord's case here rested on a clear record from the housing officer.
- Give proper written notice. Section 11(6) requires 24 hours' notice in writing. An informal call is not enough to found an application.
- Apply early. An access injunction takes time. Waiting until a deadline has passed makes the position worse.
- Do not plan on a locksmith. Until the High Court rules, forced entry may not be ordered.
For tenants
- Allow the inspection. A tenant who reports damp and mould and then refuses access may face an injunction and a later costs claim, and risks weakening any disrepair claim of their own.
- Ask who is attending and why. It is reasonable to want to know whether the visit is by a contractor or a surveyor, and how long it will take.
For surveyors
- Log failed visits. A dated no-access note with photographs of the door and a calling card can become evidence.
- Describe limits honestly. If only part of a flat could be seen, the report must say so. A diagnosis of the cause of damp needs a proper inspection, moisture readings and, where needed, monitoring.
- Separate inspection from repair. The first visit is to find the cause. Sending a decorator before a surveyor often leads to a second failed fix.
Where expert evidence fits in
No surveyor gave evidence in this case. It was about access, not about the cause of the damp. But access cases and disrepair claims often run side by side.
If a tenant later brings a claim for disrepair or unfitness for habitation, the court will want expert evidence on what is causing the damp and whether it is the landlord's responsibility. That evidence is usually given by a single joint expert or by a surveyor for each side under CPR Part 35 [2]. An expert who has been refused entry can say very little. Both sides are better served by an early joint inspection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a landlord enter without a court order if the tenant refuses?
The judgment does not support self-help entry in a case like this. The landlord's remedy was an injunction, enforced through the court.
What happens if the tenant ignores the injunction?
Breach of an injunction can be dealt with as contempt of court. The landlord would need to go back to the court.
Is this decision binding across England and Wales?
No. It is a County Court decision at first instance. Other judges have taken a different view and a higher court ruling is awaited.
Does this affect private landlords in Wimbledon?
The statutory right of access in section 11(6) applies to most short residential tenancies, private and social. The same enforcement question could arise.
Conclusion
Phoenix v Winch confirms that the court will order a tenant to give access for damp and mould works, and it casts real doubt on whether the court can go further and authorise forced entry. With County Court judges split, the answer now lies with the High Court.
Landlords in Wimbledon and across south London should tighten their access records and apply for injunctions promptly. Tenants should allow inspections and keep their own notes. Where the cause of damp is in dispute, an independent survey carried out with full access is still the fastest way to resolve it.
This article is general information on a recent judgment and is not legal advice.
References
- Phoenix Community Housing Association (Bellingham & Downham) Ltd v Winch (2026) EWCC 69. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35: Experts and Assessors. justice.gov.uk.