A waking watch that was meant to last six months ran for twelve and cost leaseholders' service charge account £203,888. The fire alarm that would have ended it cost a fraction of that. On 26 October 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) confirmed that the landlord could not recover the whole bill, and corrected the arithmetic the tribunal below had used.
Avon Ground Rents Limited v Li Jing and others (2026) UKUT 412 (LC) was decided on written representations by Judge Elizabeth Cooke. It is a short decision with a clear message for flat owners, resident management companies and freeholders across south-west London: temporary fire safety measures are recoverable only for as long as it was reasonable to keep them going.
What happened
The building is 8 Artillery Row in Westminster, a mixed-use block with 22 residential units, a car park and a ground-floor retail unit. Thirteen leaseholders challenged around £379,000 of service charges for the years 2017 to 2024 in the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), across 15 separate items, under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985.
The largest item was the waking watch:
- A fire safety assessment on 23 December 2020 recommended a 24-hour waking watch until an upgraded fire alarm was installed.
- The watch ran from January to December 2021 at a cost of £203,888, close to £4,000 a week.
- The original estimate had been £100,000 for six months.
- The landlord waited for money from the Waking Watch Relief Fund before installing the alarm, which cost somewhere between about £31,660 and £36,000.
What the First-tier Tribunal decided
The tribunal found that the alarm could reasonably have been installed by the end of July 2021 and that the landlord had unreasonably delayed. It referred to government guidance from January 2021 comparing the cost of waking watches with the cost of installing alarms. It limited the recoverable waking watch cost to £70,000, which it described as 70%, or seven months, of the original estimate.
What the Upper Tribunal decided
The landlord tried to appeal the finding about timing. Permission was refused on that point by both tribunals. The finding that the alarm should have been in by the end of July 2021 therefore stands.
Permission was granted on a narrower, computational point: why had the tribunal used the estimate when the actual cost was known?
Judge Cooke set the £70,000 figure aside. Her reasoning was straightforward:
- The only fault found against the landlord was the duration of the watch.
- The weekly rate had never been challenged by the leaseholders.
- The tribunal had said there was no explanation for the cost doubling. That was wrong. The cost doubled because six months became twelve.
She substituted £118,934.66 as the sum payable, a figure the leaseholders had themselves put forward at an earlier stage. She noted that it represents seven-twelfths of the actual cost, not 70%. An application under section 20C of the 1985 Act, which can stop a landlord adding its tribunal costs to the service charge, is still to be dealt with.
The principle
Section 19 of the 1985 Act allows a landlord to recover service charge costs only so far as they are reasonably incurred. Applied to interim fire safety measures, that produces a two-stage question:
- Was the measure reasonable when it was put in place?
- For how long was it reasonable to keep paying for it instead of carrying out the permanent fix?
Here the first answer was yes and the second was seven months. Waiting for grant funding did not justify leaving leaseholders to pay nearly £4,000 a week when an alarm costing less than ten weeks of the watch would have ended the need for it.
The decision also shows how a tribunal should quantify the result. Once the fault is identified as delay, the natural measure is the actual cost for the reasonable period.
Expert evidence in disputes like this
No expert witness or surveyor evidence is described in the Upper Tribunal's decision. The case turned on dates, the assessment recommendation, published guidance and the invoices.
In many building safety service charge disputes, expert evidence carries more of the weight. A fire engineer or chartered building surveyor may be asked to give an opinion on:
- how long it should reasonably take to specify, procure and install an alarm or other remedial measure in a building of that type;
- whether a cheaper interim measure was available;
- whether the scope and cost of the permanent works are reasonable.
An expert in the First-tier Tribunal owes an overriding duty to the tribunal, in the same way as an expert in court under CPR Part 35. The evidence should be independent, should set out the facts and assumptions relied on, and should deal fairly with points that do not help the instructing party. Where a programme is in issue, the expert should explain each step and its realistic duration, so the tribunal can see where time was lost.
Practical lessons
For leaseholders
- Ask for the fire risk assessment, the dates of every recommendation and the programme for the permanent works.
- Challenge duration as well as rate. This case was won on how long the watch lasted.
- Keep the arithmetic simple and tied to actual invoices.
For resident management and right to manage company directors
- Record every decision and the reason for it. If you wait for funding, record why and what the wait is costing.
- Compare the weekly cost of the interim measure against the cost of the fix at each board meeting.
For freeholders and managing agents
- Act promptly on fire risk assessment recommendations. Delay moves cost from the service charge to the landlord.
- Do not assume that an application for grant funding justifies a pause.
How a building surveyor can help
A pre-purchase survey of a flat should look beyond the flat itself to the block: the fire risk assessment, any interim measures in place, planned major works and the service charge history. For existing owners and management companies, a chartered building surveyor can review assessments and specifications, advise on a realistic programme and, if a dispute arises, provide independent expert evidence.
Wimbledon Surveyors carries out building surveys of flats and advises leaseholders and management companies on major works across Wimbledon, Merton and south-west London.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Avon Ground Rents v Li Jing?
It set aside the First-tier Tribunal's £70,000 figure for waking watch costs and substituted £118,934.66, being seven-twelfths of the actual cost of £203,888.
Why could the landlord not recover the full cost?
The First-tier Tribunal found that the fire alarm could reasonably have been installed by the end of July 2021 and that the landlord unreasonably delayed. Costs after that point were not reasonably incurred.
Was waiting for the Waking Watch Relief Fund a good reason for delay?
The tribunal did not accept that it justified the delay. Permission to appeal that finding was refused.
Can leaseholders challenge waking watch charges years later?
An application under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 can be made about past service charge years, subject to limitation and to anything already agreed or admitted. Take advice on your own position.
Do I need an expert to challenge fire safety service charges?
Not always. This case was decided without described expert evidence. Where the dispute is about how long works should take or what they should cost, an independent fire engineer's or surveyor's report is often decisive.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specific advice on your own circumstances.