CONTACT

Loughton Contracts v Amtico (2026) EWHC 2814 (TCC): £2.9m Failed Flooring Claim Survives Strike-Out Despite Late Particulars, Building Defect Claim Lessons for Wimbledon Owners and Surveyors (November 2026)

Building defect claims are rarely lost on the technical merits alone. They are lost on dates: when the product was delivered, when the defect was known and when the claim form was issued. Loughton Contracts Plc v The Amtico Company Limited (2026) EWHC 2814 (TCC), handed down by Mr Justice Constable on 3 November 2026, is a clear example. A flooring contractor facing a £2.9 million claim over failed flooring at a large London residential scheme issued a protective claim against its supplier, missed the deadline for its particulars of claim, and then had to resist an application to end the case before it had started.

The contractor survived. The judgment explains why, and it carries practical lessons for owners, managing agents, contractors and surveyors dealing with defects in new and recently built homes in Wimbledon and across south-west London.

What the dispute is about

Loughton installed flooring at residential developments at Wembley Park between 2018 and 2020, working for the main contractor. Amtico supplied the flooring products. The judgment records that the flooring has failed. In pre-action correspondence the main contractor holds Loughton responsible for replacement costs of £2,907,908, although it had not issued proceedings by the time of the hearing.

Loughton wants to pass that liability up the supply chain to Amtico. To protect its position on limitation it issued a claim form on 15 October 2025 without first following the pre-action protocol, with particulars of claim to follow.

What went wrong procedurally

The claim form was deemed served on 23 December 2025, so the particulars of claim were due by 7 January 2026. They were not served. On 30 January 2026 Loughton applied without notice for a stay, and on 5 February 2026 the court stayed the claim until 5 October 2026. That order did not grant relief from the earlier default.

In September 2026 Loughton asked for a further six-month stay, to 5 April 2027. Amtico refused and applied to strike out the claim or for summary judgment.

Amtico's arguments

Amtico's case was that the claim was bound to fail whatever the cause of the flooring failure:

  • Limitation. In contract, the six-year limitation period for defective goods runs from delivery at the latest. Amtico said about 97% of the orders were scheduled for delivery before 15 October 2019. Only 18 orders, worth £18,677.95, fell after that date, against orders worth £578,071.54 before it.
  • Its standard terms. Amtico relied on clauses excluding indirect loss and third-party claims, capping liability at the contract price and imposing a two-year time limit from knowledge of the problem.
  • No duty in tort. It argued that a supplier owes no duty of care for pure economic loss of this kind.

What the judge decided

Summary judgment refused

On limitation, the judge accepted that it appears probable that a significant proportion of the claim faces limitation difficulties. But Amtico's documents showed scheduled delivery dates, not actual delivery dates. There was a real prospect that delivery records would change the picture, so the defence had not been established to the standard needed for summary judgment.

On the standard terms, Amtico had not shown with sufficient certainty which terms applied. The invoices relied on were later reprints marked as duplicates, the order acknowledgements did not refer to terms, and the terms referred to other documents that were not before the court. The exclusion clauses also had to satisfy the reasonableness test under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. The burden of proving reasonableness was on Amtico, and it had served no evidence on the point.

The tort and contribution claims could not fairly be decided on a short claim form before any particulars had been served.

Relief from sanctions granted

The judge applied the three-stage test in Denton v TH White. The failure to serve particulars on time was serious and significant. The explanation, that Loughton was waiting to see what the main contractor would do, was a reason but not a good reason.

Looking at all the circumstances, however, striking out would have been disproportionate. The claim had been stayed for most of the period, no trial date had been put at risk, the claim was protective and depended on the main contractor's position, and a strike-out could extinguish claims that were in time when issued. Time for the particulars was extended.

No further long stay

Loughton did not get the six-month stay it wanted. The judge was not persuaded that a stay to April 2027 was justified. He indicated that he would hear the parties on a short, tightly defined stay for protocol correspondence, followed by directions for pleadings, targeted disclosure and possibly preliminary issues on delivery dates and the enforceability of the exclusion clauses.

Lessons for defect claims

Limitation starts earlier than most people think

For defective materials, time in contract runs from delivery, not from the day the floor starts lifting or the day a complaint arrives. On a phased development, products are delivered over many months, so each block and each order may have its own limitation date. By the time a defect appears, some of those dates may already have passed.

Keep delivery and installation records

The outcome of the next stage of this case will turn on delivery notes. Owners, managing agents and contractors should keep delivery records, batch numbers, installation dates and handover certificates for every block. A surveyor investigating a defect will ask for them at the start.

Record when the defect was first known

Contractual time limits and some statutory ones run from knowledge. A dated inspection report by a chartered surveyor, with photographs and a clear description of the failure, is the best evidence of when a defect became apparent and how far it extended at that date.

Read the supplier's terms before the dispute

Standard terms often cap liability at the price of the goods and exclude consequential loss. Whether such terms are incorporated, and whether they are reasonable, depends on evidence about how the parties actually dealt with each other.

A protective claim form is the start of the work

Issuing a claim to stop time running is sensible. It then needs particulars, or a prompt application for an extension or stay made before the deadline passes. Loughton kept its claim alive, but only after a contested hearing in the High Court.

The expert evidence still to come

No expert evidence was before the court on these applications, and the judgment does not decide why the flooring failed. That question will need expert evidence on the product, the subfloor, moisture, adhesives and installation, and probably on the scope and cost of replacement. In flooring failures, early independent testing of moisture levels and samples of the failed material is often decisive, because once the floor has been replaced the evidence has gone.

What this means for Wimbledon property owners

Flooring, cladding, roofing membranes and waterproofing failures in newer blocks follow the same pattern: an owner or leaseholder looks to the developer, who looks to the contractor, who looks to the subcontractor and supplier. Each link has its own contract, its own exclusions and its own limitation date.

If you own or manage a flat or building with a suspected defect:

  • report it in writing to the developer, landlord or warranty provider as soon as it appears;
  • commission an independent defect survey before any remedial work disturbs the evidence;
  • gather completion, handover and warranty documents;
  • take legal advice on limitation early, particularly where the building was completed five or more years ago.

How Wimbledon Surveyors can help

Our chartered building surveyors carry out defect investigations, snagging inspections and condition surveys across Wimbledon, Merton and south-west London, and prepare reports suitable for warranty claims and legal proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

What did the court decide in Loughton Contracts v Amtico?

On 3 November 2026 the Technology and Construction Court dismissed Amtico's applications for summary judgment and strike-out, granted Loughton relief from sanctions for failing to serve particulars of claim on time, and declined to grant a further six-month stay.

When does the limitation period start for defective building products?

In a contract claim it generally runs for six years from delivery of the goods at the latest, not from the date the defect is discovered.

Does this judgment decide why the flooring failed?

No. It deals only with procedural and preliminary legal points. The cause of the failure and who is responsible remain to be decided.

Why is an early defect survey important?

It records the nature and extent of the defect at a known date and preserves evidence before repairs are carried out, which matters for both liability and limitation.

This article is a general summary of a published judgment for information only and is not legal advice.